3 Common Mistakes When Color Correcting Undereye (And How to Fix Them!)

Tired of Looking Tired? Let’s Talk Undereye Color Correction

If you’re anything like me—a mom, a multitasker, and someone who just wants to look a little more awake without doing the most—you know the struggle of dark undereye circles. You’ve tried concealers, creams, and even cold spoons (yes, that TikTok trick), but something still looks…off.

The truth is, a lot of us are making the same simple mistakes when it comes to color correcting our undereyes. But don’t worry—I’ve been there, and I’ve got your back.

In this post, I’m breaking down the 3 most common mistakes people make when trying to color correct their undereye area—plus easy fixes to get that bright, refreshed look you know you deserve.

What Is Under-eye Color Correction Anyway?

Before we dive into the mistakes, let’s quickly break it down. Color correction is a technique that uses contrasting colors to neutralize discoloration on the face. For undereyes, that usually means using a peach, orange, or red-toned corrector to cancel out the blue or purple tones common with dark circles, especially on melanin-rich skin. Sounds simple, right? But one wrong move, and instead of looking fresh-faced, you’re left with a cakey, orange mess. So let’s get into what you might be doing wrong—and how to fix it.

What are some Mistakes and How to Fix

Mistake #1: Using the Wrong Shade of Corrector

Why It Happens: Not all correctors are created equal. If you’re using a corrector that’s too light or too dark for your skin tone, it won’t neutralize your dark circles—it’ll either disappear completely or look way too obvious under concealer.

How to Fix It:

• Light to medium skin tones: Opt for a peach or salmon corrector.

• Medium to deep skin tones: Go for a rich orange or terracotta (like the one I’m holding in the photo—yes, that’s the Huda Beauty Faux Filter Color Corrector in “Peach”).

• Deep skin tones: Try a red-orange or brick tone to cancel out the darkness.

Test a small amount first and blend it in to see if the undertone complements your skin. A good corrector should neutralize, not stand out.

Mistake #2: Applying Too Much Product

Why It Happens: When we see dark circles, our first instinct is to pile on the product—corrector, then concealer, then powder. But this often leads to creasing and a heavy, cakey look that emphasizes texture.

How to Fix It:

• Use a small, precise brush or fingertip to apply a thin layer of corrector only where the darkness lives.

• Less is more. You just want to neutralize, not paint on a new face.

• Blend it gently into the skin using tapping motions—don’t rub or drag.

Mistake #3: Skipping the Right Prep (Hydration Matters!)

Why It Happens: Your under-eye area is delicate and tends to be dry—especially if you’re running on little sleep (hi, motherhood!). Applying corrector directly to dry or flaky skin will make things worse.

How to Fix It:

• Always start with a hydrating eye cream to smooth the area and create a better canvas.

• Wait a minute or two for it to absorb before applying any product.

• If you’re dry, consider using a gripping primer or hydrating serum before makeup.

Bonus Tips for Undereye Success:

• Set with a light hand: Use a finely milled translucent powder to lightly set the area. Don’t bake—it can make things look crusty.

• Use a damp sponge to blend concealer over the corrector without disturbing it.

• Don’t forget to color correct after foundation if needed—sometimes your base cancels enough on its own.

Final Thoughts + Your Turn!

Undereye color correction doesn’t have to be intimidating. Once you know what to avoid and how to tailor your products to your unique skin tone, it becomes second nature.

✨ Try these tips the next time you do your makeup—and let me know in the comments if it made a difference!

Click here to check out the short Youtube video!